Andrés Duany on New Urbanism’s Legacy and Affordable Housing

As a leading advocate for smart growth, Miami-based architect and urban planner Andrés Duany's vision for housing development and affordability is both bold and practical

July 26, 2020
founded in 1979, Seaside, in Florida, is heralded as the first example of New Urbanism
Seaside—heralded as the first example of place-making using principles of New Urbanism—is an 80-acre community in Florida's Panhandle. The final plan for the community was completed in about 1985 and is the result of the efforts of Andrés Duany and Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk, with contributions by architect Léon Krier. | Photo: courtesy Duany Plater-Zyberk & Co.
Andres Duany of Duany Plater-Zyberk & Co. architects and urban planners
Andrés Duany
Founding partner
DPZ CoDESIGN and
No Nonsense Housing Company

This is a longer version of an interview that appeared in the July/August 2020 issue of Pro Builder.

Andrés Duany co-founded the planning, urban design, and architecture firm Duany Plater-Zyberk & Co. (DPZ) with his wife, Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk, in 1980 with the goal of replacing suburban sprawl with what would become “New Urbanism.” For the past four decades, he has designed hundreds of new communities and revitalized others around the globe, as well as influenced planners, architects, designers, and government policy in the U.S. and abroad. He has also co-authored several books and continues to support efforts to encourage mixed-use, walkable communities and to address the challenge of affordable housing. Pro Builder contributor Michele Lerner sat down with Duany to discuss his legacy and latest passions.

 

PRO BUILDER: What are builders and architects getting right today? What are they getting wrong?  

Andrés Duany: Dollar for dollar, the products you get from architects and builders in America are the best in the world. American builders are touchingly concerned with what people want inside their homes, so their interior layouts are also the best in the world. But in terms of the exterior of homes and the layout of communities, Americans build the worst public face in the world with the least walkable communities.

NIMBYism exists because people hate the experience of traffic and cookie-cutter housing. They love the interiors of their homes, but they don’t want more pain from traffic and they don’t want more ugliness. People hire DPZ because we can get permits to build the best private realm inside homes and the best public realm. Developers need to learn to design open space with a square or a plaza and walkable charming streets instead of tinkering with whether blue cabinets are popular this year. NIMBYism was created by American developers.

Advertisement

PB: How do New Urbanism communities stand up after 30 to 40 years?

AD: They are very successful from the point of view of the people who live there who want to walk everywhere, socialize with neighbors, and live in a multigenerational community. I think about 50% of people want to live in these kinds of communities, but there are always some who say they don’t want [that lifestyle or community]. 

The biggest mistake planners make is that they hedge their bets and design communities that are neither suburbs nor New Urbanism-—they are the worst of both. 

aerial view of Seaside community in Florida designed by Duany Plater-Zyberk & Co.
The community of Seaside, in northwest Florida, includes urban planning and building patterns found in traditional American towns. Civic buildings are spread out on selected sites throughout the community to stimulate different areas. | Photo: Moon Creek Studios
street in Seaside, Florida, community designed using principles of New Urbanism
Seaside's layout is based on the idea that everyday destinations should be within a 5-minute walk. The community features narrow, shared streets, which are intended to be comfortable and functional for pedestrians, cyclists, and motorists alike. | Photo: Flickr user Steve Tiesdell Legacy Collection (CC by 2.0)

 

PB: Is there anything you would change about Seaside or Kentlands

AD: We deployed Main Street shops as the lure to get people to socialize, but that essentially means you have to spend money to socialize. That’s profoundly unfair. I’d replace shopping with “agrarian urbanism,” which is dedicated to growing food as a community and brings people together to plant, harvest, and process it.

RELATED

 

PB: How do you assess housing affordability? 

AD: Affordability is the No. 1 problem facing the U.S. today and a major cause is the government making it difficult to get building permits. Huge regulatory hurdles have made it so hard ... you [practically need] a government subsidy to build affordable housing. 

Forty years ago, I didn’t need permits to build Seaside, but now—even with Florida’s very benevolent regulatory environment—you have to spend $1 million to $1.2 million in consulting fees to build a new community in the same area.

We’ve seen smaller builders disappear because permitting became so difficult and expensive that only big builders could afford to amortize the expense. So we started the “Lean Urbanism” initiative to help younger and smaller developers get permits and build affordable projects.

 

aerial view of the Kentlands community in Maryland, designed using principles of New Urbanism
Kentlands, in Gaithersburg, Md., is a 352-acre traditional neighborhood development (TND) northwest of Washington, D.C., that was begun in 1988 and built over more than a decade. Homes are built both close to one another and to the street to encourage residents to interact with neighbors. | Photo: Michael Watkins Architect
homes in the development of Kentlands, in Gaithersburg, Md., are located close to one another to encourage neighborly interaction
Large and small single-family homes and townhouses in the Kentlands community are built close together on relatively small lots from 2,500 to 9,000 square feet. This not only promotes neighborliness but also allows individuals of different generations and various income levels to live in the same neighborhood. | Photo: courtesy Duany Plater-Zyberk & Co.

 

PB: What cuts through the red tape?

AD: Big developers hire someone to help them get past the regulatory problems, so part of Lean Urbanism is to provide young builders with hacks to get around the burden of regulations. Regulatory reform takes too long, so this is about identifying loopholes available to builders. 

For example, it’s important to know the threshold where certain regulations kick in. If you stay within a certain size, such as four apartments on three levels, you can get a permit more easily than if you added just one more apartment per floor or another level to the building. Another hack is to renovate a building to the code under which it was built rather than today’s far more restrictive code, while still keeping people safe. 

PB: What other solutions do you advocate?

AD: In a technical sense, the manufactured home industry has already solved the affordability crisis. It can deliver homes at $50 per square foot. But it has a cultural problem. So, another initiative of ours is dedicated to making manufactured housing culturally acceptable and getting permits. 

 

tiny house by Duany Plater-Zyberk & Co. at the 2020 International Builders' Show
Show Village at the 2020 International Builders' Show, featured two Duany Plater-Zyberk homes: the Tiny Home (shown) and the Mid-Century Modern Home. The persistent challenge of providing affordable housing has focused Andrés Duany’s attention on small-scale housing, specifically high-quality modular homes, prompting him to form the No Nonsense Housing Company, with plans to build a factory to mass produce his designs.

 

PB: What about empty retail spaces and the inventory of large suburban homes?

AD: One of the greatest real estate opportunities of the 21st century is underutilized parking lots that are available because the retail sites are empty. This is pre-permitted, denatured land with access to electricity and plumbing. McMansions can be transformed into senior or student housing with parking in the back so the garage can become living space. Shopping malls and shopping centers can be converted to mixed-use town center developments with open spaces where people can gather.

 

Access a PDF of this article in Pro Builder's July/August 2020 digital edition

 

Comments

expand_less