flexiblefullpage - default
Currently Reading

Supreme Court rules against authorities that 'extort' land owners seeking permits

billboard - default

Supreme Court rules against authorities that 'extort' land owners seeking permits

The decision overturns a Florida Supreme Court ruling that would have given governments expanded power to force unreasonable exactions upon developers

By National Association of Home Builders August 26, 2013
NAHB_Supreme Court ruling_land owners seeking permits
This article first appeared in the PB August 2013 issue of Pro Builder.

In a major victory for property-rights advocates, the U.S. Supreme Court on June 25 issued an opinion that gives property owners a strong argument with which to fight certain concessions that are often required as a condition for approving a permit to develop a piece of land. The decision overturns a Florida Supreme Court ruling that would have given governments expanded power to force unreasonable exactions upon developers. The National Association of Home Builders' (NAHB) involvement helped make it happen.

The case was Koontz v. St. Johns River Water Management District, a landmark case with major implications for land developers nationwide.
Since the late 1980s, a permit condition was not considered constitutional unless it has a "nexus" to a governmental purpose, and it was "roughly proportional" to the impacts of the project. This is known as the Nollan/Dolan test, named after two Supreme Court cases. The test protects property owners from overzealous land-use permitting officials, but until now there were two outstanding questions about it: 
1) Does it apply even if the permit is denied? 
2) Does it apply if the government's condition is a payment of money?

The Court's Decision

In both instances, the Supreme Court answered in the affirmative. In the first scenario, if a property owner refuses to agree to outrageous conditions in åa permit and the government subsequently denies that permit, the government cannot later argue that because the permit was never granted, there was no constitutional violation. The Supreme Court also ruled that the Nollan/Dolan test applies equally whether the government demands the land owner give up real property or money as a condition of obtaining a permit. Tellingly, the court used a form of the word "extortion" five times to describe the manner in which governments demand property from developers before granting approvals.
This landmark decision effectively denies the government the ability to force unreasonable exactions upon developers in exchange for a permit approval, and it means that federal, state, and local regulators will need to exercise more caution to ensure that permitting demands—including monetary demands—are proportionate to the project at hand.
Leading the fight on behalf of property owners, NAHB headed a coalition of 16 prominent real estate and business organizations in filing an amicus brief that explained why it is neither necessary nor fair for governments to extort money from property owners who wish to use their land.
leaderboard2 - default

Related Stories

Women in Construction

NJ $4M Grant to Help Boost Access to Construction Trades for Women and Minorities

Through a combination of legislation and grant money, the state of New Jersey is taking steps to increase the diversity of its workforce in construction and the skilled trades

Education + Training

Annual Chico Trades Day Provides Students With Hands-on Experience

In Chico, Calif., trades take center stage at annual trades day event that introduces students to skilled trades career options

Education + Training

Indiana High School Students Gain Construction Experience Building a Home

High schoolers get hands-on experience in the skilled trades thanks to a construction program run by the Central Nine Career Center in Johnson County

boombox1 -
native1 - default
halfpage2 -

More in Category

Delaware-based Schell Brothers, our 2023 Builder of the Year, brings a refreshing approach to delivering homes and measuring success with an overriding mission of happiness

NAHB Chairman's Message: In a challenging business environment for home builders, and with higher housing costs for families, the National Association of Home Builders is working to help home builders better meet the nation's housing needs

Sure there are challenges, but overall, Pro Builder's annual Housing Forecast Survey finds home builders are optimistic about the coming year

native2 - default
halfpage1 -

Create an account

By creating an account, you agree to Pro Builder's terms of service and privacy policy.

Daily Feed Newsletter

Get Pro Builder in your inbox

Each day, Pro Builder's editors assemble the latest breaking industry news, hottest trends, and most relevant research, delivered to your inbox.

Save the stories you care about

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet lorem ipsum dolor sit amet lorem ipsum dolor sit amet.

The bookmark icon allows you to save any story to your account to read it later
Tap it once to save, and tap it again to unsave

It looks like you’re using an ad-blocker!

Pro Builder is an advertisting supported site and we noticed you have ad-blocking enabled in your browser. There are two ways you can keep reading:

Disable your ad-blocker
Disable now
Subscribe to Pro Builder
Already a member? Sign in
Become a Member

Subscribe to Pro Builder for unlimited access

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.