Tight Supply Is Keeping These Midwest Markets In Demand

Limited new construction and relatively affordable home prices are keeping demand elevated across the Midwest

Homes are becoming unaffordable in metros across the U.S., but with a tight supply of for-sale homes and relatively attainable prices, the Midwest continues to draw in high demand. According to a recent report from John Burns Research and Consulting (JBREC), the Midwest has the tightest resale housing market in the U.S., with just 2.1 months of supply.

Although eroding affordability has slowed new home sales, homeownership remains much more attainable throughout the Midwest than in many other regions. The inflow of value-oriented families and retirees, often bouncing back to areas where they previously lived, continues to offset lower demand from the local population.

- Scott Wild, principal of consulting at JBREC

Which Midwestern markets are seeing the most demand?

The nationwide median is just over two months of supply, but in some metros that's even lower. In Chicago, for instance, housing supply sits at just 1.5 months, and home values there are up by 6% year-over-year. Likewise, in Indianapolis, housing supply is at 2.1 months with home values up 5% year-over-year.

Affordability is a main driver for high demand—but so is a lack of new construction

Despite the growth in home values some Midwestern metros are seeing, they still remain relatively affordable compared with the broader nationwide housing market. Housing costs—including mortgage, taxes, and insurance—as a share of income are among the lowest in the U.S. At a 7% mortgage rate, Indianapolis has the lowest housing costs as a share of income, accounting for 26% of the total. Even Chicago, at 35%, is below the national average of 44%.

Still, these shares are higher than what the region is used to. Because of high mortgage rates, housing costs in the Midwest have grown by approximately 57% since February 2020. In Indianapolis, for example, homeowners historically spent about 17% of income on housing compared with today's 26% figure.

Cost increases are partially because of high mortgage rates, now averaging about 7%. Costs have also grown because of a lack of new construction in the region. 

About the Author

Catherine Sweeney, Content Strategist/Staff Writer

Catherine Sweeney, Content Strategist/Staff Writer

Catherine Sweeney is a content strategist and staff writer for Pro Builder and Custom Builder Online, with a focus on design trends, new products, and environmental issues. Contact her at csweeney@endeavorb2b.com.

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates