Policymakers and housing advocates seeking solutions to the housing crisis point out that home-building productivity has stagnated over the past few decades while other industries, such as automobile manufacturing, have reaped the benefits of factory productivity. So, at a time when the shortage of affordable housing is pressing, many expect that building homes off site would streamline and expedite the construction process, bringing down costs and boosting supply.
But the world of off-site housing is littered with companies that have gone bust. Mark Erlich, a former officer of the New England Regional Council of Carpenters and author of The Way We Build: Restoring Dignity to Construction Work, attributes many of these failures to outside investors' inexperience with the construction industry, Business Insider reports. But there are other factors.
Erlich said the policy landscape wasn't the most significant obstacle for the industry. More important, he argued, was the lack of consistent demand for modular buildings, the high costs of transporting a finished product to the building site, and the decentralized nature of construction. While the timeline for modular construction is consistently compressed, transportation and other costs can mean it isn't cheaper than building on-site.
Investors aren't convinced there's sufficient and consistent demand for modular housing in most markets. Modular construction is best for buildings that have repeated components, such as a hotel with hundreds of identical rooms, a dorm building, or a multi-family apartment building with identical units.
Advertisement
Related Stories
Off-Site Construction
New Study Examines Barriers and Solutions in Manufactured Housing
The study from Harvard's Joint Center looks at the challenges faced by developers using manufactured housing and how they're overcoming those barriers
Off-Site Construction
Utah Passes Bill to Regulate Modular Construction at the State Level
Goals for housing innovation and affordability meet in Utah's passage of a new bill that establishes a statewide modular construction program
Off-Site Construction
What's Standing in the Way of Home Builders Adopting Off-Site Methods?
Findings from Home Innovation Research Labs show home builders continue to embrace the status quo when it comes to adopting new methods, but results vary by builder type and region